When a puller part wears out or you need a better fit for specific calibers, the right replacement can save time and reduce frustration at the bench.
This roundup highlights the best options for compatibility, build quality, and everyday reloading convenience.
Best 10 Bullet Puller Replacement Parts Picks for 2026
Impact Puller
- Includes 3 collets and 4 o-rings
- Covers .22 Hornet to 45-70
- Won’t work with rimfire cartridges
Best For: Reloaders needing a complete impact puller setup
Pow'R Pull Part
- Works with the Pow'r Pull Kit
- Precision crafted replacement part
- Single standard chuck assembly
Best For: RCBS users replacing a worn chuck assembly
Caliber Collet
- Sized for 6.5mm bullets
- Works with a standard bullet puller
- Durable aluminum construction
Best For: Reloaders needing a 6.5mm replacement collet
Replacement Collets
- Set of three aluminum collets
- Fits .22 Hornet to 45-70
- Made for the Frankford Arsenal Impact Puller
Best For: Frankford Arsenal owners replacing worn collets
Caliber-Specific Replacement Collet
- .270 caliber collet for standard pullers
- Made for RCBS collet-style use
- Lightweight, compact replacement part
Best For: RCBS users needing a .270 caliber replacement collet
Multi-Size Impact Replacement Set
- 3 sizes included in one pack
- Fits a wide range from .22 Hornet to 45-70
- Aluminum collets with rubber O-rings
Best For: Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller users wanting multiple replacement sizes
Press-Mounted Puller Body
- Threads into 7/8-14 single-stage presses
- Built for clean jacketed bullet removal
- Collets sold separately
Best For: Reloaders building or replacing the RCBS press-mounted puller body
Expandable Collet Kit
Aluminum Different Expandable Bullet Puller Collets
- 3 expandable collets plus 3 sealing rings
- Fits calibers from .17 Remington to 50-70 Govt
- Sized for small, medium, and large cartridges
Best For: Reloaders needing a broad-compatibility replacement collet set
Universal Impact Kit
Impact Bullet Puller with 3 Collet Sets
- 3 included collets cover .22 Hornet to 45-70
- Works with rimmed and rimless cartridges
- Steel shaft and polycarbonate body
Best For: Reloaders wanting a durable all-in-one impact puller
Frankford Arsenal Replacement Set
Quick-N-EZ Impact Bullet Puller Collets
- 3 replacement aluminum collets included
- Fits bullets from 22 Hornet to 45-70
- Made to work with Frankford Arsenal puller
Best For: Quick-N-EZ owners needing direct-fit replacement collets
Impact Puller – Frankford Arsenal Quick-N-EZ
If you need bullet puller replacement parts that match a complete impact-style setup, the Frankford Arsenal Quick-N-EZ is a practical option. It’s built to separate bullets from brass with one firm whack, and the included collets make it versatile across a wide range of calibers.
Best For: Reloaders who want an impact bullet puller with included collets and basic replacement accessories.
Pros:
- Includes 3 different sized collets for broad caliber coverage.
- Comes with 4 o-rings along with the hammer and collets.
- Works from .22 Hornet up to 45-70, rimmed or rimless.
- Lightweight aluminum and heavy-duty plastic construction.
Cons:
- Will not work with rimfire cartridges.
- Replacement needs are tied to the Frankford Arsenal impact puller system.
For shooters who already use this platform, the included collets and o-rings make it a straightforward, ready-to-use setup. It’s a good fit when you want a durable impact puller rather than piecing together parts one at a time.
Pow'R Pull Part – RCBS Chuck Assembly
For anyone looking for bullet puller replacement parts for the RCBS Pow’R Pull system, this chuck assembly is the core piece to keep the tool working. It’s a simple, precision-crafted replacement part made for use with the Pow’r Pull Kit.
Best For: RCBS Pow’R Pull users who need a standard chuck assembly replacement.
Pros:
- Designed to work with the Pow’r Pull Kit.
- Precision crafted for the standard chuck assembly role.
- Compact, lightweight replacement part.
Cons:
- Only useful if you already use the Pow’R Pull system.
- Single replacement component, not a full kit.
This is a straightforward maintenance part for an RCBS puller setup, not a universal accessory. If your chuck assembly is worn or missing, it gives you the exact piece needed to restore function.
Caliber Collet – RCBS 6.5mm Bullet Puller
If you’re shopping for bullet puller replacement parts for a standard puller, this RCBS 6.5mm collet is a focused caliber-specific option. It’s designed for 6.5mm bullets and built with the durable RCBS aluminum construction buyers expect.
Best For: Reloaders who need a 6.5mm collet for a standard bullet puller.
Pros:
- Made specifically for 6.5mm caliber bullets.
- Compatible with a standard bullet puller.
- Aluminum construction for durable RCBS quality.
Cons:
- Caliber-specific, so it won’t suit other bullet sizes.
- Only one collet is included.
This is a sensible replacement when you only need one caliber insert instead of a full set. It’s best suited to reloaders who want a simple, durable part matched to a 6.5mm setup.
Replacement Collets – Frankford Arsenal 3-Pack
For buyers searching for bullet puller replacement parts, this three-piece aluminum collet set is designed as a direct replacement for the Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller. It’s a practical way to refresh the puller and keep working across a wide range of bullet sizes.
Best For: Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller owners who need replacement aluminum collets.
Pros:
- Set of three replacement aluminum collets.
- Works with bullets from .22 Hornet to 45-70.
- Designed for the Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller.
Cons:
- Only works with the Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller.
- Requires a flat surface and rubber o-ring setup for assembly.
This set makes sense if you already own the Frankford Arsenal impact tool and just need fresh collets. It offers broad caliber coverage without forcing you to replace the entire puller.
Caliber-Specific Replacement Collet – RCBS .270 Cal Collet
If you need bullet puller replacement parts for a standard RCBS setup, this .270 caliber collet is the matching component for pulling jacketed bullets cleanly. It is a caliber-specific part made for the RCBS collet-style system, so it only makes sense if you already use a compatible puller and need a .270 collet.
Best For: Reloaders using an RCBS collet-style bullet puller who need a .270 caliber replacement collet.
Pros:
- Caliber-specific .270 collet for standard bullet puller use
- Designed for durable RCBS quality
- Compact, lightweight replacement part
Cons:
- Collet only; bullet puller tool is not included
- Only fits .270 caliber applications
- Not a universal replacement part
This is a straightforward replacement piece for reloaders who already know they need a .270 collet. If your setup matches, it offers the simple, caliber-matched part swap that keeps a collet-style puller working as intended.
Multi-Size Impact Replacement Set – Universal Impact Collet Set
For shoppers comparing bullet puller replacement parts, this 3-pack aluminum collet set is aimed at impact-style use and covers a wide range of bullets. The notes say it works with just about every bullet from .22 Hornet to 45-70, making it a practical replacement kit if you want multiple sizes in one package.
Best For: Reloaders using a Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller who want a multi-size replacement collet set.
Pros:
- Includes 3 sizes in one replacement set
- Works with bullets from .22 Hornet to 45-70
- Made from aluminum with rubber O-rings
- Designed to work with Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller
Cons:
- Made for impact puller use, not all puller styles
- Requires assembling the collet and O-ring
- Replacement parts only; puller tool not included
This set makes sense if you want a broad-size replacement option instead of buying single caliber parts one at a time. The aluminum construction and included O-rings give it a practical, no-frills setup for common impact-puller jobs.
Press-Mounted Puller Body – RCBS Collet-Style Puller
If you are shopping bullet puller replacement parts, this RCBS collet-style puller is the press-mounted tool that holds the system together. It threads into a standard single-stage press with 7/8-14 threads and is designed to pull jacketed bullets cleanly, but it does require caliber-specific collets sold separately.
Best For: Reloaders who want a press-mounted RCBS bullet puller body and already have or plan to buy the needed collets separately.
Pros:
- Threads into standard single-stage presses
- Designed for controlled removal of jacketed bullets
- Compatible with caliber-specific collets sold separately
- Simple press-mounted design
Cons:
- Collets are not included
- Requires a compatible single-stage press
- Not a standalone complete puller kit
This is the right choice if you need the main RCBS puller body rather than a small replacement insert. It is a practical foundation for a collet-style setup, especially if you already own the matching caliber collets.
Expandable Collet Kit – Aluminum Different Expandable Bullet Puller Collets
If you need bullet puller replacement parts for a broad mix of calibers, this aluminum collet kit is built as a practical spare set. It includes three expandable collets plus three sealing rings, and the compatibility range covers everything from .17 Remington and .22 Hornet up through 50-70 Govt. That makes it a straightforward option for reloaders who want one replacement kit that can handle small, medium, and large cartridges.
Best For: Reloaders who want a complete replacement collet set for a wide caliber range.
Pros:
- Includes three expandable collets and three sealing rings in one kit
- Wide compatibility from .17 Remington to 50-70 Govt
- Separate collets for small, medium, and large cartridges
- Made from aluminum for a lightweight replacement option
Cons:
- Designed as collet replacement parts, not a full bullet puller tool
- Works best if you already know which collet size matches your caliber
This is a useful spare-part set for reloaders who want coverage across common and magnum cartridges without buying multiple kits. The included size breakdown makes selection simpler, especially if you work with both pistol and rifle rounds.
Universal Impact Kit – Impact Bullet Puller with 3 Collet Sets
For buyers comparing bullet puller replacement parts, this impact-style kit stands out because it includes three collet sets and covers a very wide caliber range. It is designed for both rimmed and rimless cartridges from .22 Hornet to 45-70, and the one-strike inertia design is intended to remove bullets quickly without damaging brass or deforming bullets. If you want a versatile replacement setup for a reloading bench, this kit is built to do the job across many common rounds.
Best For: Reloaders and gunsmiths who want a durable, broad-compatibility impact puller kit.
Pros:
- Includes 3 collets for broad caliber compatibility
- Works with rimmed and rimless cartridges
- One-strike impact design for fast bullet removal
- Steel shaft, polycarbonate body, and rubber O-rings for durability
Cons:
- It is a full tool kit, so it may be more than you need if you only want spare collets
- Requires a firm striking surface for proper use
Overall, this is the most versatile option in the group if you need a replacement-capable puller that can cover many calibers and cartridge types. Its durability features make it appealing for repeated bench use.
Frankford Arsenal Replacement Set – Quick-N-EZ Impact Bullet Puller Collets
If you already own the Frankford Arsenal Quick-N-EZ puller, this replacement collet set is the most direct match in the lineup. The set includes three aluminum collets and rubber O-rings, and it is designed to work with just about every bullet from 22 Hornet to 45-70. For anyone looking specifically for bullet puller replacement parts rather than a complete tool, this is the most model-specific option here.
Best For: Owners of the Frankford Arsenal Quick-N-EZ puller who need replacement collets.
Pros:
- Replacement aluminum collet set made for the Frankford Arsenal Impact Bullet Puller
- Includes three collets and rubber O-rings
- Broad fit from 22 Hornet to 45-70
- Simple setup: place on a flat surface and roll the O-ring into the groove
Cons:
- Compatibility is centered on the Frankford Arsenal puller
- Sold as replacement collets, not as a full standalone tool
This is the clearest choice if you want a replacement set for an existing Quick-N-EZ system. Its value comes from the direct fit and the familiar caliber coverage, especially for reloaders who only need spare parts.
How We Picked Bullet Puller Replacement Parts
We focused on parts and accessories that are commonly needed for impact and collet-style pullers, with an emphasis on compatibility, material quality, and ease of swapping. For Bullet Puller Replacement Parts, the best choices are the ones that match your press or puller system cleanly and hold up under repeated use.
Quick Comparison
Use impact-style replacement collets if you need broad caliber flexibility and fast setup. Choose collet-style assemblies or pull chucks if you want more controlled use on a press. Universal kits and multi-size sets are best when you load several calibers and want one backup solution for the bench.
Key Buying Factors for Bullet Puller Replacement Parts
Compatibility
Check whether the part is made for impact pullers, collet pullers, or a specific brand such as RCBS or Frankford Arsenal. A close fit matters more than a long feature list.
Caliber Range
If you work across .22 to larger hunting calibers, a multi-collet set can be more practical than a single replacement piece. Match the collet size to the bullets you pull most often.
Material and Durability
Aluminum collets are lightweight and common in replacement kits, but they should still feel precise and well-machined. Look for parts that resist deformation and maintain grip after repeated strikes or cycles.
Ease of Use
The best replacement parts install quickly, seat securely, and do not require extra tuning. That matters when you need a tool that works efficiently under normal reloading conditions.
Kit Value
Sets with multiple sizes can be a better value than buying single parts one at a time, especially if you keep backup components on hand.
Who Should Buy Which Bullet Puller Replacement Parts?
Choose a single OEM replacement if you already know your exact puller model and want a direct swap. Pick a multi-size aluminum set if you reload several calibers or want spares ready. If you are building a versatile bench setup, a universal impact puller kit is often the most flexible option. The best Bullet Puller Replacement Parts are the ones that match your workflow, your press, and the calibers you handle most often.